Monday, February 8, 2010

Did Manning blow the Superbowl? Maybe...

So now Superbowl XLIV is in the books.  The New Orleans Saints shocked the world and won a game they were supposed to be happy to even find themselves in.  Bourbon Street is ecstatic and so is just about every Peyton Manning hater out there.

The hot topic in the sports media today is "Did Peyton Manning forever tarnish his legacy by throwing a pick six and blowing the Superbowl?"

I am thoroughly convinced that, no, "The Pick Six" isn't what blew the Superbowl.

However, Peyton Manning, the only quarterback in the NFL to call his own plays, did.

That's not to take credit away from the Saints.  Drew Brees put on a passing clinic, the Saints' team hustled, and their coaches, frankly, "outcoached" the Colts'.

First, let's look at what the Saints did right, starting with their gameplan.

The Saints were pretty conservative and ball control oriented in the first half.  This had a lot of people scratching their heads early on, as they expected to see the Saints spreading the Colts out to throw.

However, as Chris Brown over on Smart Football explained wonderfully, the Saints offense is extremely multiple in its formations as well as their plays.  They did a fantastic job of putting the Colts defense in conflict with their various formations and matchups, giving Drew Brees some open receivers to throw to as well as the time to get the ball out to them.  This game should be shown to all NFL offensive coordinators for years as part of a clinic presentation on "NFL Offense 101."

The conservative strategy really seemed to control the pace of the game early on for the Saints, calming the offense down and letting it feel things out and get into a groove without risking turnovers. It also kept them from getting into a shootout and losing their minds when they were down 10-0 early, too.

In short, they let the game come to them on their terms.  All of this really started making a difference in the second quarter, where the Saints limited the Colts to just 6 offensive snaps and took command of the game despite still trailing at halftime 10-6.

Sean Payton's management of the game was brilliant.  While the onside kick to open the second half has gotten most of the media attention, I believe Payton's best call was really the unsuccessful 4th down attempt near at the Colts goal line in the closing minutes of the half.

Payton smartly believed that even if the Saints were unsuccessful, they had pinned the Colts inside the 5 yard line, that the Colts would be trying for the quick score themselves and that with timeouts remaining the Saints had a chance to still get a field goal before the half if they could just force a quick 3 and out.

All of that stuff came to pass.  Payton found a way for the Saints to both have their cake (trying for a TD on 4th down) and eat it too (still get points out of this situation even if the attempt was unsuccessful).

The onside kick was also a brilliant job of scouting and coaching.  In postgame interviews, the players said that the Saints' coaching staff had noticed on film that the Colts' Hank Baskett had a habit of bailing too soon on kickoffs, so they went right after him. Payton announced the onside kick to his players at the beginning of halftime after they'd practiced it all week. This is an excellent job of paying attention to details and exploiting them through planning and preparation.

Further, the Saints' Defensive Coordinator Greg Williams had three seperate ready-made gameplans for Manning in this game: a first half plan (mostly conservative zone defense), a third quarter plan (a little tougher package of zone pressure and blitzes that overloaded a side of the Colts' pass protection), and then an additional fourth quarter plan to really blitz and get after Manning with man coverage behind it.

Still, the Saints could not have came back from a 10-0 deficit if it hadn't been for the Colts' mistakes, mistakes that go far beyond "Pick Six" in the fourth quarter.  Caldwell's team had failed to notice or address Baskett's problems on kickoff returns when he could be observed on film commiting a cardinal sin there, a mistake that would have gotten him benched on many high school teams.

For anyone who thinks that special teams play is overrated, the huge swing in momentum AND the denial of an entire position to the Colts offense should really demonstrate how important they truly are.

You could tell that the Saints' ball control was getting to Manning in the 2nd quarter.  The cameras kept cutting to shots of Manning looking angry and frustrated as he sat on the bench alone, helpless and unable to get back out or stay on the field.

From his expression, you'd think his team was losing by 40, not leading by 7.  He would maintain that expression throughout the game as the Colts first lost the lead, then regained it, then lost it and kissed any chance of a win goodbye with "The Pick Six" and a stalled two minute drill.

I believe this really impacted the Colts' in the second half.  Manning, the Colts' playcaller, basically abandoned the run in the second half in favor of trying to force passes between defenders.  He had some beauties, like the "how-did-he-do-that?" throw to Dallas Clark on the third quarter touchdown drive, but Manning only let the Colts run the ball a total of 8 times for 27 yards in the second half, despite his team protecting a lead for most of that span. 

It's also worth noting that 24 of those yards, and 4 of those attempts, came on the Colts first drive of the second half, which went for a touchdown.  Manning's crushing Pick Six came after 8 straight pass attempts and 14 passes over the Colts' previous 17 offensive plays.  Of the Colts 37 plays in the second half, the Colts passed on over 81% despite having a great deal of success running the ball in the first half.

That is predictability, and numerous statistical analysis have shown that running the ball is the safest way to protect a lead: teams who pass the ball when nursing a lead tend to lose far more often than those who commit to running it.  Since Manning fiercely insists on maintaining his autonomy to call plays at the line, it was not Jim Caldwell's decisions that caused this, though he is getting roasted by commentators and fans ignorant of this fact.

It's especially disappointing since Joseph Addai had such a great first half and was giving the Saints fits on draws and traps.  On only 7 carries, Addai had shredded the Saints defense in the first half for 60 yards and appeared to be the MVP in the making at halftime (many still believe he should've been MVP of the last Colts Superbowl win).  In the second half, however, Manning tried to take over the game himself and took the ball out of Addai's hands.  A 17-16 lead turned into a 31-17 loss.

Addai only had 17 yards on 6 carries in the second half, with 3 of those coming for 19 yards on the Colts final touchdown drive in the 3rd quarter.  He had only 3 carries for -2 yards in the fourth quarter, both pre-and-post Pick Six.  The result: the Colts went from nursing a 17-16 lead to sputtering offensively, Manning threw a pick six to put the game away, and then any hope of a comeback died in a failed two minute drill where Addai carried the ball only once for -2 yards near the goalline.

We can make all sorts of speculation on WHY Manning chose to abandon the running game for the Colts when protecting a lead in the second half of a big game, just as he's done countless times before in his career going back to his college days.  Such blovating and unfounded B.S. would be unfair to Manning, one of the game's hardest workers and most intense competitors.  However, the numbers do hint that Manning's decisions when calling the plays may have cost himself and the Colts a second Superbowl ring.

Coaches will tell you that playcalling is overrated and I'll agree, but this was a textbook example of how it can and does matter.

Yes, Virginia, the Colts CAN lay a heaping portion of the blame for this loss on Peyton Manning.  However, they must credit him for guiding the team this far.  If not for Manning, the Colts are basically Dwight Freeney, Dallas Clark, Reggie Wayne, and a bunch of guys no one would have ever heard of.

Let's not forget that he is still the league's best passer and that his resume includes many of the best seasons of all-time, at least statistically, ever recorded by a quarterback.  One play did not cost this game anymore than it cost Peyton Manning a certain first ballot Hall of Fame induction, and it's possible that he'll be back in a future Superbowl before it's all said and done.

For the Colts' sake, let's hope he remembers it's still legal to run the ball next time.


  1. Great write-up.

    Although, I kinda thought that G Williams relied pretty heavily on C1 (man) concepts for a great deal of the game as evidenced by the 46 concepts being utilized in the 1st half.

    I certainly wouldn't fault Manning for doing all he could in the 2nd half to continue exploiting the matchups by throwing the ball. If Wayne, Collie, Garcon, and Clark make these catches, would we be second-guessing Manning? I dunno. He is the franchise and it IS what the Colts do. Keep in mind that running the ball hasn't been the Colt's penchant this season and the 2nd level penetration by the Saints (leading to negative yardage plays) didn't help matters in choosing to rely on the run game after the Saints limited the opening 2nd half possessions

  2. I think the NFL fixes the super bowl sometimes. I think they felt like New Orleans winning would be be the better story.
    Look at some of the most recent super bowls, a few of those results are questionable.

  3. I was curious if you ever thought of changing the layout of your blog?
    Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so
    people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text
    for only having one or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it
    out better?
    Have a look at my homepage :: games online

  4. Additional Info

    Look into my webpage :: attorney leads
    Also visit my homepage ... lawyer leads

  5. This page definitely has all the information and facts I needed about this subject and
    didn't know who to ask.

    Check out my website - how to make money fast and easy
    my webpage: how to make money at home online

  6. Hey There. I discovered your blog the use of msn.
    This is a really well written article. I'll be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your helpful info. Thank you for the post. I will certainly return.

    Feel free to visit my web page weight loss encouragement

  7. I'm really impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a nice blog like this one nowadays.

    Here is my web page ... waist to height calculator

  8. things hard to build, difficult to replace, and costly
    to substitute. Often that's what prospects do when you annoy them with your barketing. An estimated 80% of Americans between the ages of 33 and 44 use the internet as a tool for research, shopping and banking.

    my web blog check this out

  9. Undeniably believe that which you stated. Your favorite justification seemed to be on the web the simplest thing to be aware of.
    I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly don't know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

    Take a look at my homepage :: how do you hack an email

  10. I might lovе tο see а chrome battery ρoweг, what guy dοesn't like chrome,or perhaps stainless steel?

    my web site Green Smoke Quebec

  11. Excellent web site you have here.. It's difficult to find high quality writing like yours these days. I really appreciate people like you! Take care!!

    My website; ford ranger

  12. You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something which I think I would
    never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me.
    I am looking forward for your next post, I'll try to get the hang of it!

    Feel free to surf to my blog post: Fail Compilation 2012

  13. Yes! Finally someone writes about extant.

    my blog; Louis Vuitton Bags

  14. Thankfulness to my fаther who stated to mе гegаrding this wеbpаge, this
    webpage iѕ in fact amаzing.

    Mу weblog

  15. Apple ωill be the fіrst Αpple device tо
    get 4 G LTE device. Αpplе, ωhich dеmanԁs high levels оf secrecy and secuгitу from suрpliеrs
    and employees, woulԁ not comment. Also, the iphone 4 out thеre.

  16. With havin so much written content do you ever run into any problems
    of plagorism or copyright violation? My blog has a lot of exclusive
    content I've either created myself or outsourced but it appears a lot of it is popping it up all over the web without my permission. Do you know any techniques to help reduce content from being stolen? I'd really appreciate it.

    Here is my web blog :: counter strike 1.6 aim Cheat

  17. Good way of telling, and good article to take information regarding my presentation subject matter, which i
    am going to deliver in institution of higher education.

    My web page: Louis Vuitton Handbags

  18. Wow, this piece of writing is good, my sister is analyzing these kinds of things, thus I am going to tell

    my website: minecraftforfree

  19. I гeally like your blog.. vеrу nice colors & thеme.
    Did you design thiѕ ωebsitе yoursеlf or did you
    hіre someone to do it for you? Plz rеsponԁ as ӏ'm looking to construct my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. kudos

    My web blog - forever

  20. This is a toріc whiсh is neaг to my heart.

    .. Thаnk you! Exаctly ωhere are уouг сοntаct detаils

    Feel free to νisit mу wеb pаge - forever living products aloe vera

  21. Ӏf yοu desire to grοw your know-how simplу kеeρ viѕiting this ѕite anԁ be updаteԁ wіth the mоѕt recеnt nеws postеd hеrе.

    Check out my рage :: forever

  22. If some оne ԁesіres expеrt view regarding blogging and site-building after
    that i rеcоmmenԁ him/hеr to pay a visit thiѕ weblοg, Keер up the nісe woгk.

    Have а lοok at my wеb-site Aloe

  23. Ϻу partnеr anԁ I stumbled over hеre
    bу а different ωeb adԁrеss anԁ thought Ι
    mаy as ωell check thіngs οut.
    I lіke what I sеe so now i аm folloωing you.
    Look forwarԁ to looking at your wеb page for а secοnd time.

    Also visit my web sitе; Aloe Vera Plant